Mathématiques
What Is an Improper Fraction?
If the top number is at least as big as the bottom one, the fraction is improper. 7/4 is 1 3/4 — and improper is the form you keep for multiplying.
Improper fraction
An improper fraction is one whose numerator is greater than or equal to its denominator, so its value is 1 or more — for example 7/4.
- Aussi appelé
- top-heavy fraction
- Où les élèves le rencontrent
- Grade 4 to 6; in England, converting between improper fractions and mixed numbers is a Year 5 objective in the national curriculum.
La réponse en bref
An improper fraction has a numerator at least as large as its denominator, so it is worth 1 or more: 7/4, 9/2 and 5/5 are all improper. It is not an error. 7/4 is the same number as the mixed number 1 3/4, and the improper form is the one to keep when multiplying or dividing.
Un exemple
7/4 = 1 3/4
Seven quarters. Four of them make one whole and three are left over, which is what 1 3/4 records. Nothing has been calculated in any real sense — the same quantity has been described twice, once by counting quarters and once by counting wholes first and quarters afterwards.
One comparison settles it
Look at the two numbers. If the top is smaller than the bottom, the fraction is proper and worth less than 1. If the top is at least as large as the bottom, it is improper and worth 1 or more. There is nothing else to check, and no picture is needed.
5/5 is the case that provokes an argument. It is exactly 1, and under the usual convention — numerator greater than or equal to denominator — it counts as improper. A few textbooks require the numerator to be strictly larger. This is a labelling preference and it has never changed the value of anything.
Counting your way between the two forms
Going from 7/4 to a mixed number is a question about how many whole ones are hidden inside seven quarters. Four quarters make one whole, which leaves three quarters over, so 7/4 is 1 3/4. Nineteen quarters would give four wholes with three quarters spare, or 4 3/4.
Coming back is the same count run in reverse. In 2 3/5 the two wholes are worth five fifths each, which is ten fifths, and the three fifths already written brings the total to thirteen fifths: 13/5. Framing both directions as counting rather than as a rule about multiplying and adding is what stops a student applying the rule to the wrong pair of numbers.
Improper does not mean incorrect
The name is doing real damage here. Improper is a description of the shape of the fraction, not a verdict on it, and an answer left as 7/4 is a complete answer unless the question has asked for something else.
More than that, it is the form to work in. Multiplication and division of fractions want everything as a single fraction, so 2 1/2 × 3/4 has to become 5/2 × 3/4 before anything sensible can happen. Converting to a mixed number, if it is wanted at all, belongs at the very end.
Questions fréquentes
Is 5/5 an improper fraction?
Under the usual definition, yes, because the numerator is not smaller than the denominator. Its value is exactly 1. A small number of textbooks insist the top must be strictly larger, which would exclude it — worth knowing so that a disagreement with a classmate does not turn into a lost afternoon.
Should I convert my answer to a mixed number?
Only if the question asks. Both forms name the same number, and neither is more correct. A mixed number reads better for a measurement, since 2 3/4 hours is easier to picture than 11/4 hours, but if the next line of working involves multiplying, leave it improper.
Why do improper fractions exist at all?
Because a fraction is a count of equal parts, and there is no reason the count must stop at one whole. Seven quarters is a perfectly ordinary quantity. The improper form also keeps the arithmetic honest: every rule for multiplying and dividing fractions assumes a single top number and a single bottom one.
Is an improper fraction always greater than 1?
Greater than or equal to 1. The only case that lands exactly on 1 is where the two numbers match, as in 3/3 or 5/5. Every other improper fraction, such as 7/4 or 9/2, is genuinely larger than a whole.
Sources
- National curriculum in England: mathematics programmes of study — Department for Education
Dernière mise à jour
Connaître le mot n'est pas savoir s'en servir
Un professeur peut voir un élève s'en servir dans un exercice et repérer exactement où la compréhension s'arrête. Le premier cours est gratuit.